The phone alarm that listened for silence
A 1974 Lifeline patent for a phone alarm that went off when the phone went quiet, and how a 1989 ad turned a pendant into a catchphrase.
On this page
A phone that worried when it went quiet
One early medical alert idea listened for silence. A patent application that Lifeline Systems filed in 1974 described a telephone alarm that went off when the phone sat unused for too long 1. The design kept a 24 hour clock running and restarted it every time someone picked up the handset 1. More than a decade later, a different company's TV ad made one line famous: "I've fallen and I can't get up" 4.
A question asked in 1972
In 1972, gerontologist Andrew Dibner asked himself a simple question: what would an older person living alone do if something went wrong and nobody was around 2? Lifeline says he and his wife Susan, a sociologist, turned the answer into a company, Lifeline Systems, Inc., founded in 1974 2.
U.S. patent 3,989,900 was filed on November 4, 1974 and granted on November 2, 1976, with Dibner named as the inventor 1.
How the quiet phone alarm worked
The clever part was how little it asked of its owner. A timer ticked away in the background, and normal phone habits, like answering, dialing or just lifting the receiver, sent it back to zero 1. If the phone sat untouched for the whole period, the device dialed numbers recorded in advance and played a warning message to each 1. A bell rang at the same moment, and picking up the handset was all it took to cancel a false alarm 1. For anyone able to reach it, a manual emergency switch was also built in 1.
The patent explains the thinking. Earlier call-for-help devices, it says, mostly depended on the person setting them off, which someone badly incapacitated might not be able to do 1. It also describes an earlier alarm from Sweden called The Watchman, wired to everyday switches such as a bathroom or refrigerator light 1. Dibner's version put everything into the one object a person living alone already touched every day: the household telephone 1.
The ad line nobody could forget
The famous catchphrase is a line spoken in television commercials for LifeCall, a different medical alarm company that no longer exists 5. CBC Radio's Under the Influence describes a long-running commercial that began in 1989, built around a small pendant whose button put the wearer through to an emergency response service 4. The ad was played completely straight, and yet one line turned it into a cult classic 4.
Who said it first depends on which source you read. CBC credits a woman named Edith Fore and says she spoke the line to the operator after a real fall in which she hit her head 4. Wikipedia instead describes Fore playing a character called Mrs. Fletcher, with a stuntperson doing the fall 5. It adds three more twists: actress Dorothy McHugh speaking the line in a 1987 LifeCall ad, Fore saying in a 1990 interview that she made it up at a script conference, and competitor Life Alert claiming a 1985 commercial as the origin 5. Wikipedia sums it up plainly: the origin of the line is in dispute 5.
From punchline to trademark
Beyond the ad, the phrase showed up on T-shirts, bumper stickers and novelty records, and stand-up comedians leaned on it again and again 4. Sitcoms such as The Golden Girls, Roseanne and The Fresh Prince of Bel Air worked it into scripts 4. "Weird Al" Yankovic even sampled it in his 1992 song "I Can't Watch This" 5.
The words also became property. LifeCall registered the phrase as a trademark in September 1992, closed its doors in 1993, and the registration was cancelled in 1999 5. In June 2007, the phrase became a registered trademark of Life Alert 5.
Worth watching: how one emergency number came to be
Every alarm in this story works by placing a phone call, so the story of the emergency number itself makes a natural companion. In this Today I Found Out video, the channel looks at how Americans once had to know a separate number for each police or fire department, and how a single emergency number for North America came about.
Where to go next
If the history has you curious about the devices as they exist now, our overview of medical alert systems lays out home and mobile setups and their monthly prices. For a closer look at what one provider charges each month, there is our monthly cost comparison. And for families sharing the work of looking after a parent, our guide to care coordination apps covers tools people use to stay in sync.
Sources
Keep reading
We may be paid when you sign up through links on this page. This site is not a medical provider and nothing on it is medical advice; talk to a qualified clinician about your own health. How we make money